Sunday, February 13, 2011

"Two Views of the River"

"Two Views of the River" by Mark Twain is a memoir that has many Realism characteristics, but also serves as an example of the shift from Romanticism to Realism in literature. Mark Twain starts off this memoir by describing how he once saw the river. Judging from where he is from, it's a pretty safe bet to say that the river in question is the Mississippi River. Anyway, he starts off by saying that he once saw the river as breathtakingly beautiful. This is when he first moved to a location close to the river. He was in awe of the beauty of the sunset. He describes it in vivid detail and extols its beauty. He then goes on to say that the longer he lived there and worked on a steamboat, the less he saw the beauty of the water. He only saw how much it could tell him. "Then if that sunset scene had been repeated, I should have looked upon it, inwardly, after this fashion: This sun means that we are going to have wind tomorrow; that floating log means that the river is rising..." (Twain 505). He is looking at it in a more analytical way. This represents the shift from Romanticism to Realism. Previously, Romantic authors would have been hung up on how naturally beautiful the river was, like Twain was at the beginning of this story. Writers eventually began to look at things more practically, also drawing upon the old style of Rationalism. This whole memoir excerpt is basically a giant analogy for the shift in thought patterns and writing styles.

Realism and Regionalism are the main components of this work. Realism is present in the more analytical style of writing and the use of unembellished words. Fortunately, Realism is not as unadorned a writing style as Puritanism, but it is less flowery than Romanticism. Also a noteworthy characteristic of Realism that is present in "Two Views of the River" is the use of figurative language. Twain consistently compares his plight to that of a doctor. He no longer sees the beauty of the river, while a doctor cannot see the beauty of a woman for all the medical information running through his head. "Are not all her visible charms sown thick with what are to him the signs and symbols of hidden decay?" (Twain 505).

Regionalism is also present in "Two Views of the River". Twain describes the setting in great detail, both when he can still see the beauty and when he cannot. Both descriptions are very detailed in their respective ways. The setting is very important in a Regionalism work. The setting is so important that it can practically be considered its own character (Campbell). Twain draws particular attention to it, as it is the way he notices the changes in himself (Twain). The region he is in is also important. If he had not become a steamboat worker on the river, he would not have become immune to the beauty of that particular region. He also would not have been able to see its beauty in the first place. He ponders on whether it was worth it in the end.

Campbell, Donna M. "Regionalism and Local Color Fiction." Washington State University - Pullman, Washington. 20 Jan. 2011. Web. 13 Feb. 2011. http://www.wsu.edu/~campbelld/amlit/lcolor.html.

Twain, Mark. From "Two Views of the River." Glencoe Literature. Ed. Jeffrey Wilhelm. American Literature ed. Columbus: McGraw-Hill, 2010. 504-505. Print.

"The Celebrated Jumping Frogs of Calaveras County"

Mark Twain's "The Celebrated Jumping Frogs of Calaveras County" is a good example of Regionalism. As mentioned earlier in this blog, Mark Twain was a key author of the Regionalism movement. A pioneer of his field, if you will. He was one of the first authors to start writing in the local dialect. For Twain, his dialect was a lazy Southern drawl, and it shows in "The Celebrated Jumping Frogs of Calaveras County". there are many examples of the local dialect, such as when Simon Wheeler talks about how Smiley "learned" a from to jump (Twain 501). People do not say that anymore- they say taught. Also in the lines, "There was a feller here once by the name of Jim Smiley in th winter of '49 - or may be it was the spring of '50 - I don't recollect exactly..." (Twain 499) This local dialect is used so much as to become a nuciance. This was a common occurence in Regionalism. "The Celebrated Jumping Frogs of Calaveras County" reads much like other works by Twain such as The Adventures of Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn. My favorite local saying used in this story was when Smiley realized his frog has been stuffed with metal and he says, "Why, blame my cats, if he don't weigh five pound!" (Twain 502). Why anyone would want to blame their cats in such a situation is beyond me, but I found the bit of local color quite amusing. It was the same case with the word "bananner" (Twain 502). Also, the use of a steamboat simile to describe a dog helps establish where this story takes place.

This story is also a work of Realism because it depicts events that could plausibly happen in real life. I remember having frog-jumping contests every Fourth of July. It is not that much of a stretch to imagine a man teaching a frog to jump, particularly if that man had a gambling problem. Jim Smiley himself was the ideal Realism hero. He was an ordinary many who lived in small town America. He liked to gamble more than the average man, but small town life does that to a person.

Government and religion are also missing from this story as well. It seems that these were not very important in Realism works. The American dream is also shuffled to the background. Nature is described only in the barest sense to establish where the events of the story are taking place. Human nature is evident in the man from the city's actions. The man cheats on their bet because he wants to win. It is within human nature to want to win all the time, this man just take it one step further to show us a darker side of his nature. There is not enough of this to make "The Celebrated Jumping Frogs of Calaveras County" at Naturalism work, though. The lack of a dire situation also makes certain that this story is not a Naturalism work. It is, however, a Realism and Regionalism work, as explained above.

Twain, Mark. "The Celebrated Jumping Frogs of Calaveras County." Glencoe Literature. Ed. Jeffrey Wilhelm. American Literature ed. Colombus: McGraw-Hill, 2010. 498-502. Print.

Stephen Crane

This excerpt from The Red Badge of Courage shows predominantly Naturalism characteristics with a thin veil of Realism on top. Prior knowledge of the novel is extremely helpful when analyzing this excerpt. I know for a fact that I was not the only one of my classmates that was confused as to what this was about. We got a basic summary from our teacher, which helped a lot. Even ignoring the background information that I got, it was still evident that there were Naturalism characteristics. The main reason this is a Naturalistic work is the psychology at work here. The man appears to be in the middle of a battlefield during a battle. This setting in itself is a quality of Naturalism. Naturalism played on the survival instinct, and what better place to show that than on a battlefield? Wars also cause great emotional stress for those fighting in them. Soldiers come home all the time with various mental disorders, the most common being Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. The man in this story was in a "red rage" (Crane 493). His emotions push him forward, but his cowardance and his inexperience pull him back. The detailed way in which these emotins are depicted hints at Realism. The situation itself is also Realistic because it depicts an event that could actually happen. I am sure that many veterans could confirm that they felt emotions similar to these during their first battle.

Religion and government are not at all present in this excerpt. It makes sense that they would not be considering the situation. There is hardly time for anything in a battle, let alone government. The soldiers really probably only had time to say a quick prayer before their attention shifted to survival, and this excerpt is apparently after that time. The American Dream is also not wholly represented in this. The part about gaining glory could be found if you looked hard enough. This man obviously wants to prove himself, and it is driving him crazy that he cannot because apparently he is a coward. Nature is not described in this portion of the novel. I am sure that it is later, but not in the three paragraphs in question. The Hero is a common Realism character. He seems to be an ordinary man who finds himself in a drastic situation where he must survive. Figurative language is sed very creatively here. "Buried in the smoke of many rifles his anger was directed not so much against the men whom he knew were rushing toward him as against the swirling battle phantoms which were choking him, stuffing their smoke robes down his parched throat." (Crane 493) is my favorite example. That imagery really stuck out to me. I love how he makes the battle into a real entity that is trying to make things as hard as possible for the soldiers on both sides. The regular language was also indicative of Realism. There is no dialogue though, so we cannot see whether there is a dialect or not to indicate Regionalism.

Crane, Stephen. "from The Red Badge of Courage." Glencoe Literature. Ed. Jeffrey Wilhelm. American Literature ed. Colombus: McGraw-Hill, 2010. 493. Print.

Kate Chopin

The excerpt from Kate Chopin's The Awakening shows many Naturalism characteristics. For one thing, the woman who is the main focus is uncontrollably sobbing. The story even says that she does not know why she is crying, other than that she is having a "good cry all to herself" (Chopin "Awakening" 491). She feels oppressed by society and stifled by her husband's kindness toward her. These depressing emotions have been associated with Naturalism for a long time now, whether it was originally supposed to be that way or not. Either way, those emotions bring the human nature and psychological aspect into this story. The idea of fate as a driving force is also brought up in this excerpt, which is also a characteristic of Naturalism. "She did not sit there inwardly upbraiding her husband, lamenting at Fate, which had directed her footsteps to the path which they had taken." (Chopin "Awakening" 491). This quote states that she was not mourning her fate, but it does establish the belief in fate that was a staple of Naturalism.

The other story featured in this blog is Chopin's "The Story of an Hour". This was probably my favorite one so far. It describes a woman who learns that her husband has died in an accident. Instead of feeling sad, like one might expect, she is happy that he is no longer around to control her. When thought upon, this makes sense. At the time this was written, men had almost complete control over their wives. Women were just starting to fight for their equal rights and to raise awareness. So, anyway, she is really happy because she is finally "Free! Body and soul free!" (Chopin "Story" 555). Then her husband comes home and she dies of sadness. Again, we see the depressing emotions that have become intertwined with Naturalism through the years. This story deals with the psychological aspect of Naturalism more than any of the others so far. The wife's reasons for feeling the way that she does are explained in detail. That detail is also characteristic of Naturalism and Realism in general. Chopin describes the room the woman is n, and how her face looks as she cries.

Both of these stories could have happened in real life, which is a ringing endorsement for Realism. Women cry to themselves all the time. Many have good reason to. Also, people's husband's could be mistakenly reported dead, it's happened often enough. Society at the time was very realistically portrayed in both of these stories. Government, religion, and nature are not very prominent in these stories. The American Dream is present in the form of the Women's American Dream. Both of the main women want to be free from the oppression of the men in order for there to be "no one to live for her... she would live for herself." (Chopin "Story" 555). The heroines of these stories would, in my opinion, be able to live such a life quite comfortably. It sounds like they have already been through so much, so they deserve to have their American Dream come true.


Chopin, Kate. "The Awakening." Glencoe Literature. Comp. Jeffrey Wilhelm. American Literature ed. Columbus; McGraw-Hill, 2010. 491. Print.

Chopin, Kate. "The Story of an Hour." Glencoe Literature. Comp. Jeffrey Wilhelm. American Literature ed. Columbus; McGraw-Hill, 2010. 554-555. Print.

Willa Cather

Willa Cather's O Pioneers! has many characteristics of Realism and Regionalism. O Pioneers! reads like a biography of the Bergson brothers. At least the excerpt in question does. The writing is plain and simple. Things are described in detail, such as the wooden sidewalks. Cather includes that they are wooden when such a detail was unnecessary. Realism authors often included seemingly unimportant details for the purpose of helping the reader to imagine the scene. The events described in O Pioneers! could happen in reality. At the time period, this happened quite a bit. In today's world such events would be unheard of, but at the time, Westward expansion was still around and still a pretty big deal.

Cather's "A Wagner Matinee" describes just that. A matinee concert performance of various pieces by Wagner. Such a thing could have actually happened at some point in time. It actually did quite frequently when orchestra performances were still a popular form of entertainment. The main characters are the narrator and his Aunt Georgiana. He hasn't seen her in a while, so he is happy to spend time with her while she is in Boston. The narrator is an ordinary man living in Boston, and his aunt is a typical homesteader out in Nebraska. Both characters were of lower middle-class society, which is a common trait of Realism heroes. Also common to Realism is the writng style. The words are unpretentious and very descriptive. Details that could be considered unnecesarry are also included in "A Wagener Matinee" such as when the narrator is describing the clothing of the ladies at the concert: "and there was only the color of bodices past counting, the shimmer of fabrics soft and firm, silky and sheer; red, mauve, pink, blue, lilac, purple, ecru, rose, yellow, cream, and white..." (Cather "Wagner" 524). While colorful, that description was really not needed in order to further the plot.

Religion is not a topic in either work up for discussion in this blog, nor is government. Nature is discussed briefly in O Pioneers!, but not in "A Wagner Matinee". In O Pioneers! the drought is described as well as what the land they settled on looks like. Human nature is not mentioned in depth, but is able to be seen. In O Pioneers! the Bergson brothers' nature is mentioned, the author saying that "The Bergson boys, certainly, would have been happier with their uncle Otto, in the bakery shop in Chicago." (Cather "O" 489). The American Dream is a part of both of these works because they are both about pioneers/homesteaders who wanted to go someplace new and try to live out the dream there. Government is not discussed in either work at all. There is some beautiful figurative language in "A Wagner Matinee". I especially liked the metaphor about the violins and the bows: "She sat mutely staring at the violin bows that drove obliquely downward, like the pelting streaks of rain in a summer shower." (Cather "Wagner" 525). The imagery is amazing and descriptive at the same time, which keeps the Realism feel to the whole simile.


Cather, Willa. "A Wagner Matinée." Glencoe American Literature. comp. Wilhelm, Jeffery. McGraw Hill. Columbus, OH. 2009. 521-526. Print.

Cather, Willa. "O Pioneers!" Glencoe American Literature. comp. Wilhelm, Jeffery. McGraw Hill. Columbus, OH. 2009. 489. Print.

Letter to Robert E. Lee's Family

In "Letter to His Family", Robert E. Lee, shows himself to be a very intelligent man. He can see that the nation is falling apart and is mourning the loss by writing to his son. His version of the American Dream is to have America be whole once again. This letter was written before the Civil War. Not all of the states had seceded yet, but they were getting that way. Lee could see that it was inevitable that something would happen, which is a characteristic of Naturalism.

There are also several characteristics of Realism in this letter. The most obvious being that Robert E. Lee was an actual person, thus the events that he spoke of in his letter actually happened. He is an important historical figure who is writing about things that could and did actually happen in real life. Naturally Robert E. Lee could not have known for sure that a Civil War would break out, but it was still a possibility in his time. He was also an ordinary man. The ordinary, everyday man was a prominent fixture in Realism. Again, Robert E. Lee could not have known at the time that he wrote this letter that he would become an important man in America's history. Those of us in today's time have the benefit of history and retrospect and know that he was eventually very important. He was not at the time he wrote this, so he can still be considered a Realism hero. Another characteristic of Realism that is easy to see is that this letter is written in the vernacular. Lee was writing this letter to his son, so he had no need for fancy words. He would obviously be relaxed when dealing with his family, so his word choice makes sense.

Regionalism is also apparent. Lee says that if the Union is dissolved, he will "return to my native state and share the miseries of my people." (Lee 385). This closeness to his native area is indicative of Regionalism.

Nature and psychology are not components of this letter. Government is mentioned in practically the whole thing because Lee spends the majority of this letter mourning the loss of the great nation of Washington's time. "How his spirit would be grieved could he see the wreck of his mighty labors!" (Lee 385). Religion is also included, but is not the main focus. In these lines, "...We are between a state of anarchy and civil war. May God avert both of these evils from us! I fear that mankind will not for years be sufficiently Christianized to bear the absence of restraint and force," (Lee 385) Lee is asking for God to help them during this time. Lee's American Dream is just to keep America together. he does not want the country to break up and fight against each other. He just wants to keep living his life according to The American Dream. His views reflect the feelings of many Americans at that time. Only small groups actually wanted to go to war, but many saw it as inevitable.

Lee, Robert E. "Letter to his Son." Glencoe Literature. Ed. Jeffrey Wilhelm. American Literature ed. Colombus: McGraw-Hill, 2010. 385. Print.

"And Ain't I a Woman?"

"And Ain't I a Woman?" was an address to the Ohio Women's Rights Convention in 1851 delivered by Sojourner Truth, an important activist for women's and slave's rights. This speech is more Regionalist than Realist or Naturalist. Regionalism works use the dialect of the characters' area. Since this is a speech, there are no definite characters, but the dialect is still there. Even in the title of the speech, the rest of the speech's word usage should be apparent. The use of the word "ain't" should point toward a background in the South, which Sojourner Truth has. The reader can also infer that Truth felt very comfortable with her audience. She even converses with them and points them out at times such as when she says, "Then they talk about this thing in the head; what's this they call it?" Someone in the audience whispers intellect and Truth responds with "That's it, honey." (Truth 370). This plain, relaxed dialogue is indicative of Regionalism.

This speech is not very closely associated with naturalism. It does feature a common heroine from a lower class of society, but that is about it. There is not really any human nature at play here, unless you count wanting to be equal with men a part of human nature. Truth does not take a psychological approach to her view on equality for women. This speech is also not in any way about survival or fate, so it would not fit very comfortably under the title of a Naturalist work. Sojourner Truth is also not the type of woman to sit back and let fate play out. No, she is going to fight for women's rights. This is another thing that sets her apart from Naturalist writers. She did not trust in fate to get her out of slavery, and she did not trust in fate to get equal rights for women.

This speech could also be called Realism in nature because Truth presented a scenario that did actually happen in real life. She was also pretty detailed in her complaints against men. For example, "That man over there says that women need to be helped into carriages, and lifted over ditches, and to have the best place everywhere. Nobody ever helps me into carriages, or over mud-puddles, or gives me any best place! And ain't I a woman?" (Truth 370). She gets specific, and calls upon things that a man actually said he thought women needed help with. She tells the truth that women deserve equal rights to men in a frank and understandable manner. This is also in the style of Realism.

This was a very powerful speech, despite its short length. It is fortunate that we had a forward-thinker like her to bring about women's rights. She thought about realistic ways to get equality for women, and her speech "And Ain't I a Woman", reflects her Realist attitude. To some, this speech may sound like bitter complaints from a bitter woman, but for the most part, I think she was just stating the facts that she had seen throughout her life and saying that something needed to change.

Truth, Sojourner. "And Ain't I a Woman?" Glencoe Literature. Comp. Jeffery D. Wilhelm. American Literature ed. Columbus: McGraw-Hill, 2010. 370. Print.